晨间信号Morning Signal
《怀疑探索者》 第50卷 第1期 · 约 2025年12月 · 中文解读

反牛顿主义是否启发了地平说运动?

Did The Anti-Newtonian Inspire the Flat-Earth Movement? · Glenn Branch
约 18 分钟Feature在小程序里点播,20 到 60 分钟做好
这篇讲什么
本文探讨了匿名小册子《反牛顿主义》的作者身份及其对地平说运动的影响,认为其作者是詹姆斯·福斯伯里,但缺乏证据表明他影响了罗博瑟姆。
原文开头
When Kelly Weill begins her capsule history of the modern flat-earth movement in the opening chapters of her recent book Off the Edge (Weill 2022; reviewed in Branch 2022), she credits Samuel Birley Rowbotham (1816-1884), who wrote under the pseudonym "Parallax," as its prime mover. In doing so, she agrees with the general scholarly consensus: for example, Christine Garwood's definitive history Flat Earth credits Rowbotham as responsible for the "modern public revival of the flat-earth idea" (Garwood 2007, 36). But following the late Robert J. Schadewald, Weill also hints at a precursor: "an anonymous author had self-published a short booklet called The Anti-Newtonian in 1819 ... …
摘自《怀疑探索者》(Skeptical Inquirer)第50卷 第1期 · 约 2025年12月,Glenn Branch。仅引用开头一小段供了解文章,版权归原刊所有,全文请阅读原刊。
晨间信号小程序码
微信扫码,在小程序里听完整版
不用登录先听一篇 · 或在微信搜索小程序 晨间信号
同期其他文章